Local Business Invisible? Fix It With Citations!

Running a local business in today's digital landscape feels like shouting into the void sometimes. You've got an amazing product or service, loyal customers who love what you do, but somehow new customers can't seem to find you online. Here's the brutal truth: 46% of local businesses remain virtually invisible in search results, while 32% of consumers research local businesses multiple times every week. If your business isn't showing up when potential customers search for services in your area, you're essentially handing money directly to your competitors who figured out the citation game.

The invisible business problem isn't just about missing a few online mentions. It's about losing real revenue from customers who never discover you exist. Think about it - when someone in your neighborhood searches for "plumber near me" or "best pizza delivery," where does your business appear? If you're not in the top results on Google Maps or showing up in local directory listings, those customers will call someone else. The solution isn't complicated, but it requires understanding how local citations work and implementing a systematic approach to fix your online visibility problem once and for all.

Understanding Local Citations: The Foundation of Local Business Visibility

What Are Local Citations and Why They Control Your Online Visibility

Local citations represent the digital fingerprints of your business scattered across the internet. Every time your business name, address, and phone number (NAP) appear together online, you've created a citation. These mentions show up everywhere - from major platforms like Google Maps and Yelp to smaller industry directories, social media profiles, local chamber of commerce websites, and even casual mentions in blog posts or news articles. Search engines use these citations like digital detectives, cross-referencing information to verify your business actually exists and operates where you claim it does.

The citation ecosystem extends far beyond what most business owners realize. Data aggregators like Birdeye and Data Axle collect business information and distribute it to hundreds of smaller directories automatically. This means one accurate citation submission can multiply into dozens of listings, while one mistake can spread incorrect information across the entire web. Your citations appear in mapping applications that people use for directions, review platforms where customers share experiences, industry-specific directories that professionals consult, and social media platforms where people discover local businesses. Understanding this interconnected web helps explain why citation management dramatically impacts your local business online visibility.

Types of Citations That Impact Local Business Discovery

Structured citations follow a standardized format found in traditional business directories. These listings typically include your business name, complete address, phone number, website URL, business category, and operating hours in clearly defined fields. Yellow Pages, Yelp, Google Business Profile, and industry-specific directories like OpenTable for restaurants or Healthgrades for medical practices represent classic structured citation examples. These platforms make it easy for search engines to extract and verify your business information because the data follows predictable patterns.

Unstructured citations appear more naturally within content like blog posts, news articles, social media updates, or forum discussions. When a local food blogger mentions your restaurant in a review or a community newsletter features your business in an article, you've earned unstructured citations. These mentions often feel more authentic to both search engines and potential customers because they typically include context about your business quality or community involvement. The combination of structured and unstructured citations creates a comprehensive online presence that signals legitimacy and popularity to search algorithms while providing multiple discovery paths for potential customers.

The Citation-Visibility Connection: How Search Engines Use Citations

Google's local ranking algorithm treats citations as votes of confidence in your business legitimacy. When search engines find consistent NAP information across multiple reputable websites, they gain confidence that your business actually exists and operates at the claimed location. This trust factor directly influences where your business appears in local search results and Google's coveted "local pack" - those three businesses displayed prominently with map pins when someone searches for local services.

Citation consistency acts as a crucial trust signal that search engines use to combat fake or spam businesses. When your business information matches exactly across dozens of platforms, it becomes nearly impossible for search algorithms to dismiss your business as fraudulent. Conversely, inconsistent citations create confusion that can dramatically hurt your rankings. If search engines find your phone number listed differently across platforms or discover conflicting address information, they may question your business legitimacy and lower your visibility accordingly. This explains why businesses with strong citation profiles often dominate local search results while companies with citation gaps remain invisible to potential customers.

Why Citations Are Critical for Local Business SEO Success

Local SEO vs. Traditional SEO: Understanding the Difference

Local SEO focuses specifically on helping businesses appear in location-based searches, while traditional SEO targets broader, often national or international audiences. When someone searches for "coffee shop" without location context, they might find articles about coffee shop chains or general information about coffee culture. However, when they search for "coffee shop near me" or "best coffee in Denver," search engines prioritize local businesses with strong citation profiles and geographic relevance. This fundamental difference means local businesses need entirely different optimization strategies than e-commerce or national service companies.

Geographic search intent drives most local business discovery, making citations exponentially more valuable than traditional backlinks for location-based companies. Local pack rankings correlate strongly with citation quantity, quality, and consistency across platforms. Mobile search behavior amplifies this importance because people often search for local services while actively traveling to or already present in specific areas. Your citation profile helps search engines understand not just that your business exists, but exactly where it operates and how it connects to local community networks through directory partnerships and local organization memberships.

The Business Impact of Citation Invisibility

Real businesses lose real money when citation problems keep them invisible online. Consider a local restaurant that recently relocated but never updated their address across online directories. Potential customers trying to visit based on outdated citation information arrive at an empty building, assume the restaurant closed, and choose competitors instead. Meanwhile, delivery services can't find the new location, eliminating an entire revenue stream until citation corrections spread through the system.

Revenue implications extend beyond immediate customer confusion. Poor local search visibility means missing out on the growing segment of consumers who research local businesses multiple times weekly before making purchasing decisions. These informed customers often become the most valuable clients because they've already demonstrated buying intent through their research behavior. When citation inconsistencies or gaps prevent your business from appearing in their research results, you lose opportunities to build relationships with precisely the customers most likely to generate long-term value for your business.

Citation Benefits Beyond Search Rankings

High-quality citations provide valuable backlink opportunities from established, high-authority websites that search engines trust. Directory sites like Yelp, Better Business Bureau, and industry association listings often have strong domain authority that can boost your website's overall search engine credibility. These backlinks work differently than traditional link building because they come naturally from legitimate business verification processes rather than artificial link schemes that search engines penalize.

Citations create multiple customer discovery touchpoints throughout the buying journey. Someone might first encounter your business through a Google Maps search, research reviews on Yelp, check your Better Business Bureau rating, and finally visit your website before making contact. Each citation platform serves different customer needs and preferences, expanding your potential reach far beyond what any single marketing channel could achieve. Professional credibility builds naturally as customers encounter consistent business information across trusted platforms, while brand awareness expands within local market segments through diverse directory exposure.

Essential Citation Sources to Fix Your Invisible Local Business

The Big Four: Must-Have Citations for Immediate Visibility

Google Business Profile stands as the single most important citation for any local business because it directly feeds Google Maps and local search results. Claiming and verifying your Google Business Profile involves several critical steps beyond basic information entry. You'll need to verify your location through postcard confirmation, optimize your business categories for maximum relevance, upload high-quality photos that showcase your products or services, and maintain accurate operating hours including holiday schedules. Google's algorithm heavily weights the completeness and accuracy of Business Profile information when determining local search rankings.

Bing Places for Business represents Microsoft's growing influence in local search, especially as voice search through Cortana and integration with Microsoft products expands. Apple Maps connects directly to iOS users who represent a significant portion of mobile search traffic, making Apple Business Connect essential for reaching iPhone users seeking local services. Facebook Business Pages function as both social media presence and citation source, particularly powerful because Facebook's massive user base often discovers local businesses through social recommendations and location-based posts. These four platforms form the foundation of local business online visibility because they connect directly to the search and mapping tools people use most frequently.

Major Directory Platforms That Boost Local Business Visibility

Yelp dominates review-driven local discovery, particularly for restaurants, retail businesses, and service providers where customer experience matters significantly. Beyond basic listing creation, Yelp success requires active engagement with customer reviews, regular photo updates, and strategic use of Yelp's business tools like check-in offers and event listings. Yellow Pages maintains relevance despite declining print usage because their online directory feeds information to numerous smaller platforms and their established domain authority provides valuable SEO benefits.

Better Business Bureau listings offer unique credibility benefits because consumers associate BBB accreditation with trustworthiness and ethical business practices. While BBB membership requires fees and adherence to specific standards, the citation value often justifies the investment through improved customer confidence and search engine trust signals. Foursquare and Swarm provide location-based citation opportunities that connect to social discovery patterns, particularly valuable for businesses in entertainment, dining, and retail sectors where social sharing drives customer acquisition.

Industry-Specific Citation Goldmines

Restaurant citations require specialized platforms that cater to dining discovery patterns and reservation systems. OpenTable provides both citation value and functional booking capabilities that directly generate revenue through online reservations. Zomato, TripAdvisor, and delivery platforms like DoorDash and Uber Eats create citations while providing additional revenue channels. Each platform serves different customer segments - TripAdvisor attracts tourists and special occasion diners, while delivery platforms capture convenience-focused customers.

Contractor citations focus on platforms where homeowners research service providers and compare qualifications. Angie's List, HomeAdvisor, and Thumbtack combine citation benefits with lead generation opportunities, though businesses should carefully evaluate the cost-per-lead economics of paid platforms. Healthcare citations through Healthgrades, Vitals, and WebMD provide essential credibility for medical practices while connecting to patients actively researching healthcare providers. Professional association directories and certification body listings add authority signals that both search engines and potential clients value when evaluating service provider qualifications.

Geographic Citation Strategies for Hyper-Local Visibility

City-specific business directories and municipal websites provide concentrated local relevance that search engines weight heavily for geographic queries. Many cities maintain official business directories or economic development websites that list local companies, providing high-value citations with strong local authority signals. These municipal citations often cost little or nothing while delivering significant local SEO value because they come from officially recognized local government sources.

Regional publications, local newspapers, and community magazines offer unstructured citation opportunities through business features, community event coverage, and local advertising. Chamber of Commerce membership typically includes directory listings that provide both citation value and networking opportunities with other local business owners. Neighborhood association websites, community boards, and local event listings create hyper-local citations that help businesses dominate very specific geographic areas within larger metropolitan markets.

Citation Audit: Discovering Why Your Local Business Stays Invisible

DIY Citation Detection and Analysis Methods

Manual citation discovery starts with systematic Google searches using specific search operators to find existing business mentions. Search for your business name in quotes combined with your city name, then try variations with your phone number or address to uncover citations you might have forgotten about. Use Google's site-specific search function to check major platforms individually - for example, "site:yelp.com [your business name]" reveals whether you have Yelp listings you're not managing.

Competitor citation analysis provides valuable insights into citation opportunities you're missing. Research businesses similar to yours in the same geographic area and document where they maintain citations. Tools like Google search operators can help identify competitor citation sources by searching for their business information across different platforms. Social media mention monitoring through free tools like Google Alerts helps track unstructured citations in blog posts, news articles, and social media discussions. Set up alerts for your business name, owner names, and branded terms to capture mentions you might otherwise miss.

Professional Citation Management Tools and Platforms

BrightLocal's Local Citation Finder provides comprehensive citation discovery and management capabilities specifically designed for local businesses. The platform identifies existing citations, finds new opportunities, and tracks citation consistency across hundreds of directories. Their citation audit reports highlight NAP inconsistencies and provide specific recommendations for improving citation quality and quantity.

Moz Local offers automated citation distribution and monitoring services that submit business information to major data aggregators and directories simultaneously. Their platform tracks citation status changes and alerts businesses to inconsistencies or new citation opportunities. Uberall provides enterprise-level citation management for businesses with multiple locations, offering bulk submission capabilities and detailed analytics on citation performance. When evaluating citation management tools, consider factors like directory coverage, automation capabilities, reporting quality, and integration with existing marketing tools.

Common Citation Problems That Keep Businesses Invisible

NAP inconsistencies represent the most common and damaging citation problem facing local businesses. Small variations like "St." versus "Street" or different phone number formats across platforms confuse search engines and reduce citation effectiveness. Address inconsistencies become particularly problematic for businesses in suite buildings or shared spaces where unit numbers might be formatted differently across platforms.

Duplicate listings create serious problems because they dilute citation authority and confuse both search engines and customers. Duplicate issues often arise when businesses change names, relocate, or when multiple people submit listings for the same business. Data aggregator errors can spread outdated information across dozens of platforms simultaneously, requiring systematic correction efforts to fix widespread misinformation. Missing category selections and incomplete profiles reduce citation effectiveness because search engines can't properly categorize businesses for relevant local searches.

Step-by-Step Citation Building Strategy for Maximum Local Visibility

Phase 1 - Foundation Citations for Quick Visibility Boost

Google Business Profile optimization requires meticulous attention to detail because this single listing influences most local search visibility. Start by claiming your profile through the Google Business verification process, which typically involves receiving a postcard with a verification code at your business address. Complete every available field including business description, attributes, services, and products. Upload high-quality photos that showcase your business interior, exterior, team members, and products or services in action.

Core directory submissions should follow standardized NAP formatting established during Google Business Profile setup. Create accounts on Yelp, Bing Places, Apple Business Connect, and Facebook Business Pages using identical information formatting. Document your standardized NAP format in a master spreadsheet that includes exact formatting for business name, address, phone number, website URL, and business description. This reference document ensures consistency across all future citation submissions and prevents the formatting variations that damage citation effectiveness.

Phase 2 - Expansion Citations for Broader Local Reach

Industry-specific directory identification requires research into platforms where your target customers search for businesses like yours. Restaurant owners should prioritize food-focused platforms like Zomato and OpenTable, while contractors should focus on HomeAdvisor and Angie's List. Healthcare providers benefit from medical directories like Healthgrades, while retail businesses should pursue shopping directories and local business listings.

Local publication outreach involves identifying community newspapers, magazines, and blogs that feature local businesses through articles, interviews, or community spotlights. Reach out to editors with story ideas about your business's community involvement, unique services, or interesting backstory. These editorial mentions create valuable unstructured citations while building brand awareness within your local market. Community involvement opportunities like sponsoring local events, joining chamber of commerce, or participating in charity initiatives often generate natural citations through event listings and organizational websites.

Phase 3 - Advanced Citation Strategies for Market Domination

Schema markup implementation enhances citation effectiveness by providing search engines with structured data about your business location, services, and operating details. LocalBusiness schema markup helps search engines understand your business type, location, contact information, and relationship to other local entities. This technical optimization improves your chances of appearing in rich search results and local knowledge panels.

Review platform optimization extends beyond basic listing creation to active reputation management and customer engagement. Respond professionally to all reviews, both positive and negative, to demonstrate customer service commitment. Encourage satisfied customers to leave reviews across multiple platforms to build comprehensive online reputation. Local link building through citation relationships involves converting directory listings into valuable website backlinks through profile optimization and content marketing efforts that naturally attract links from local websites and blogs.

Citation Consistency: The Secret to Transforming Invisible Businesses

NAP Standardization Best Practices

Phone number formatting consistency prevents search engine confusion that can damage citation effectiveness. Choose between national format (555) 123-4567 or local format 555-1234 and use the same formatting across every platform. Avoid mixing formats or using different numbers for different locations unless you operate distinct business locations that require separate contact methods.

Address standardization requires careful attention to abbreviations, directional indicators, and suite numbers. Use either "Street" or "St." consistently, never mixing abbreviations within your citation profile. Suite numbers should follow identical formatting like "Suite 100" or "Ste 100" across all platforms. Business name consistency becomes crucial for companies operating under multiple names or DBA registrations - choose one primary name format and stick with it religiously across all citation sources.

Managing Citations During Business Changes

Address relocation requires systematic citation updates across every platform where your business maintains listings. Create a comprehensive list of all existing citations before moving, then update each platform individually with new location information. Some platforms update immediately while others require manual verification processes that can take weeks to complete. Plan citation updates well in advance of physical relocation to minimize customer confusion and search engine ranking disruptions.

Phone number migration strategies involve maintaining old numbers as forwarding lines until citation updates propagate across all platforms. Business name evolution during rebranding requires similar systematic approach - update major platforms first, then work through smaller directories and industry-specific listings. Document all changes in your citation management spreadsheet to track update progress and ensure no platforms get overlooked during transition periods.

Citation Quality Control and Monitoring Systems

Monthly citation audits should become routine business practice like financial statement reviews or inventory management. Set calendar reminders to check major citation platforms for accuracy, completeness, and any unauthorized changes. Automated monitoring tools can alert you to citation inconsistencies or new listings that appear without your knowledge, but manual verification ensures nothing slips through automated filters.

Customer feedback often reveals citation problems before automated tools detect them. Train staff to ask customers how they found your business and document any confusion about business location, hours, or contact information. These real-world insights help identify citation accuracy problems that impact actual customer experience rather than just theoretical SEO metrics.

Advanced Local Citation Strategies for Competitive Advantage

Technical Citation Optimization

LocalBusiness schema markup provides search engines with detailed, structured information about your business that goes beyond basic NAP data. Implement schema markup on your website to specify business type, service areas, operating hours, accepted payment methods, and relationships with other local businesses. This structured data helps search engines understand your business context and improves your chances of appearing in enhanced local search features.

Rich snippets creation involves optimizing citation content to appear in featured search results with additional information like star ratings, photos, or business attributes. Focus on platforms that allow detailed business descriptions and attribute selections because this information often feeds into rich snippet displays. Mobile optimization for citation platforms ensures your business information displays correctly on smartphone and tablet devices where most local searches occur.

Review-Driven Citation Enhancement

Yelp strategy requires understanding their algorithm preferences for active, engaging businesses with fresh content and regular customer interaction. Upload new photos regularly, respond to reviews promptly, and use Yelp's business tools like check-in offers to demonstrate active engagement. Google reviews integration with Business Profile optimization involves encouraging customers to leave reviews while maintaining response rates that signal excellent customer service.

Industry-specific review platforms often provide more targeted citation value than general review sites. Medical practices benefit more from Healthgrades reviews than general Yelp reviews, while restaurants see better results from food-focused platforms like Zomato or OpenTable. Reputation management through citation platform engagement involves monitoring all review sources and maintaining consistent customer service standards across every platform where customers can share experiences.

Content Marketing and Citation Synergy

Local blog outreach creates unstructured citation opportunities through guest posting, business features, and community event coverage. Identify local bloggers, community websites, and neighborhood publications that accept business spotlights or expert commentary. Provide valuable content that naturally includes business information while serving readers' interests rather than purely promotional messaging.

Press release distribution for business milestones, community involvement, or unique services generates citations through news coverage and online distribution networks. Community event participation creates natural citation opportunities through event listings, sponsor recognition, and participant directories. Partnership marketing with complementary local businesses can generate mutual citations through cross-promotion and collaborative content creation.

Measuring Citation Success: From Invisible to Market Leader

Key Performance Indicators for Citation Campaigns

Local search ranking improvements provide the most direct measure of citation campaign effectiveness. Track your business position for key local search terms before beginning citation work, then monitor monthly changes in rankings. Use tools like Google Search Console to track impressions and clicks from local search queries, paying particular attention to map pack appearances and local knowledge panel displays.

Google Business Profile insights offer detailed analytics on customer interactions generated through your primary citation source. Monitor metrics like profile views, website clicks, direction requests, and phone calls to understand how citation visibility translates into customer action. Website traffic attribution from citation sources requires proper analytics setup to track referral traffic from directory listings and review platforms back to your website.

ROI Analysis for Citation Investments

Cost-per-acquisition improvements through citations often provide exceptional return on investment compared to paid advertising methods. Calculate the customer lifetime value of clients acquired through citation-driven discovery versus other marketing channels to understand true ROI. Many businesses find citation work generates customers with higher lifetime value because these customers typically research thoroughly before making contact, resulting in more qualified leads and better client relationships.

Citation campaign budget allocation should prioritize high-impact, low-cost opportunities first. Free directory submissions and Google Business Profile optimization provide immediate returns without ongoing costs. Paid citation services and premium directory memberships should be evaluated based on lead generation potential and competitive advantage in your specific market area.

Long-Term Citation Strategy Planning

Quarterly citation audits and expansion planning help maintain competitive advantage as new platforms emerge and existing directories change requirements. Set regular review periods to assess citation performance, identify new opportunities, and address any consistency issues that develop over time. Emerging platform identification requires staying current with local search trends and new directory services that might benefit your specific industry or geographic area.

Seasonal citation optimization aligns with business cycles and local search patterns. Restaurants might emphasize outdoor dining citations during summer months, while tax preparation services should optimize citations heavily during tax season. Multi-location citation management becomes increasingly complex as businesses expand, requiring systematic approaches to maintain consistency across multiple markets while adapting to local preferences and platform availability.

Common Citation Pitfalls That Keep Local Businesses Invisible

The Duplicate Listing Catastrophe

Duplicate citations confuse search engines and dilute the authority signals that improve local search rankings. When multiple listings exist for the same business with slight variations in information, search engines can't determine which version contains accurate data. This confusion often results in reduced visibility for all listings rather than improved rankings from multiple citations.

Citation cleanup strategies require systematic identification and merger of duplicate listings across all platforms. Start with major directories like Google, Yelp, and Yellow Pages where duplicates cause the most damage. Most platforms provide tools for claiming and merging duplicate listings, though the process often requires verification steps and patience while changes propagate through data systems. Prevention systems for avoiding future duplication include maintaining detailed records of all citation submissions and training staff members who might create listings to check for existing profiles first.

Inconsistent Information Syndrome

Small NAP variations create surprisingly large impacts on citation effectiveness and local search performance. Search engines interpret inconsistent information as signs of unreliable or potentially fraudulent businesses, reducing trust signals that influence local rankings. Phone number variations like mixing (555) 123-4567 with 555.123.4567 formats across platforms create confusion that damages overall citation portfolio effectiveness.

Manual verification processes become essential for maintaining citation accuracy over time. Automated submission tools sometimes introduce formatting errors or fail to account for platform-specific requirements, creating inconsistencies that require manual correction. Team coordination ensures all staff members who might interact with online business listings understand the importance of consistency and know where to find standardized business information for any necessary updates.

Citation Neglect and Decay

Citation information becomes outdated gradually as businesses evolve, platforms change requirements, and data aggregators spread old information to new directories. Seasonal hour changes, temporary service modifications, and staff turnover can create citation accuracy problems that accumulate over time without regular maintenance attention.

Technology changes affecting citation platforms require ongoing monitoring and adaptation. Platforms frequently update their interfaces, requirements, and data fields, sometimes causing previously accurate listings to become incomplete or incorrectly formatted. Competitive citation monitoring helps maintain awareness of how your citation profile compares to local competitors and identifies opportunities for improvement or expansion.

Your 90-Day Roadmap from Invisible Local Business to Market Domination

Immediate Action Steps (Days 1-30)

Complete Google Business Profile optimization represents your highest-priority citation task because this single listing influences most local search visibility. Claim your profile, complete verification through postcard confirmation, and fill out every available information field with carefully formatted business details. Upload high-quality photos showcasing your business, products, or services from multiple angles and contexts.

Audit existing citations for consistency issues by searching for your business across major platforms and documenting any information variations you discover. Create a master spreadsheet with standardized NAP formatting that will guide all future citation work. Submit to the top 10 essential citation sources including Yelp, Bing Places, Apple Business Connect, Facebook, Yellow Pages, and relevant industry directories. Focus on accuracy and completeness rather than speed during this foundation-building phase.

Growth Phase Strategies (Days 31-60)

Expand to industry-specific citation platforms that serve your particular business type and target customer base. Research where your competitors maintain citations and identify opportunities you're missing. Launch local content marketing efforts to earn unstructured citations through community blog features, local news coverage, and social media mentions that naturally include business information.

Implement citation monitoring and management systems using tools like Google Alerts for your business name and BrightLocal or Moz Local for comprehensive tracking. Begin competitive citation analysis to understand how your citation profile compares to successful local competitors and identify gaps in your coverage that need attention.

Market Leadership Phase (Days 61-90)

Advanced technical optimization through schema markup implementation helps search engines better understand and display your business information in enhanced search results. Launch systematic review generation campaigns across multiple platforms to build comprehensive online reputation while earning additional citation value through review platform profiles.

Develop partnership citation strategies with complementary local businesses, community organizations, and industry associations that can provide mutual citation benefits through collaboration and cross-promotion. Establish long-term citation maintenance protocols including monthly audit schedules, quarterly expansion planning, and annual strategy reviews to maintain competitive advantage as markets evolve.

Professional vs. DIY Citation Management

Time investment requirements for effective citation building typically demand 10-15 hours monthly for comprehensive citation management including discovery, submission, monitoring, and maintenance activities. Skill development needs include understanding platform requirements, technical optimization techniques, and reputation management across multiple review platforms.

Professional service evaluation should consider factors like directory coverage, submission accuracy, ongoing monitoring capabilities, and integration with existing marketing efforts. Cost-benefit analysis often favors professional services for businesses with limited time or technical expertise, while DIY approaches work well for businesses with dedicated marketing staff and systematic processes. Hybrid approaches combining professional setup with internal maintenance often provide optimal balance of expertise and cost control for growing local businesses.

The path from invisible local business to market leader requires systematic citation building, consistent maintenance, and strategic expansion over time. Start with foundation citations on major platforms, expand to industry-specific directories, and maintain consistent information across all platforms. Your local customers are searching for businesses like yours every day - make sure they can find you when they need what you offer. The citation work you do today determines whether tomorrow's customers discover your business or call your competitors instead.